So, it turns out that my Madoka and Gertrud pixels were actually "draw overs".
So, I took Candlelit's advice, and made this with Pencil Tool on Photoshop.
It only took me a bit, and it's obviously Kayami.
How is it? Rate and critique!
BTW, if you can't see it, I'm posting it on DeviantArt.
http://mayufantage.deviantart.com/