Subject: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Thu Dec 23, 2010 6:37 pm
How are they different and how are they similar????
♥cherry♥ Senior Fantagian
Posts : 436 Join date : 2010-12-09 Location : Up your butt and around the corner
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Thu Dec 23, 2010 8:12 pm
well their alike because non-members cant get member things. Plus there different because non member penguins cant get any clothing only belts and a friendship braclet and back rounds.
Alola72 Junior Fantagian
Posts : 72 Join date : 2010-09-25 Age : 23 Location : B.C (Canada)
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Thu Dec 23, 2010 10:06 pm
Well, here it is... Clubpenguin sucks and Fantage rocks! That's the diffrence!
yvonnelol Senior Fantagian
Posts : 346 Join date : 2010-03-20 Location : This is a new episode of Punk'd.
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Thu Dec 23, 2010 11:12 pm
Alola72 wrote:
Well, here it is... Clubpenguin sucks and Fantage rocks! That's the diffrence!
Well, that is just an opinion, so you shouldn't have added the "Clubpenguin sucks" part. You should've left it alone, 'cuz they are just 2 virtual worlds, y'know.
racchel2107 Senior Fantagian
Posts : 270 Join date : 2010-11-12 Age : 28 Location : venus!
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 24, 2010 8:31 am
ya club penguin is useless because the only thing you see is penguins wobbling everywhere
i vote for fantage at least its more realistic then club penguins theres only penguins whats so cool bout that!?
♥cherry♥ Senior Fantagian
Posts : 436 Join date : 2010-12-09 Location : Up your butt and around the corner
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 24, 2010 10:01 am
racchel is right because fantage is not about animals its about real looking people THAT AT LEAST WEAR CLOTHING WHEN U CREATE THEM!!!! In my opinion I think more people in my school should play Fantage because only two of my friends play Fabtage because I thought them.
Magdaleena Expert Fantagian
Posts : 2261 Join date : 2010-04-26 Age : 28 Location : Somewhere in northern Europe. Probably hours ahead of you.
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 24, 2010 10:03 am
Well, let's do a comparison:
Pets: In Club Penguin, there are puffles you actually have to care for, and they run away if you don't. Certain puffles can join you in certain games when you walk them while going to that game. (Like, purple puffles join you in Dance Contest because they like to dance, red puffles join you in Catchin' Waves because they like adventure, etc.) And you can actually NAME THEM. Anyone who owns a puffle can walk their puffle. Nonmembers can get two different puffles; Blue and red. As of now, there are 9 different puffles.
In Fantage, pets are collectable like Pokemon. You can choose between displaying them like trophies in your barn, or put them in your home to care for them. If you win more than 10 games with them, they'll have a medal floating over their head wherever they are. And they hatch from eggs. You can't name them. Only members can walk them, even though nons can own them. And there are what, 35 different pets to collect? My number may be a little off, but whatever. The point is that there is a lot. You can take them into minigames specifically designed for them. There's also this creature arena, where you TURN INTO a creature you bought. I must admit that I considered this the pet feature of Fantage until those collectible pets came.
Who's better when it comes to Pets? Club Penguin, no doubt.
Achievement system: In Club Penguin, they've recently released Stamps. You get Stamps for doing certain things, and if you get all the stamps for a game, you get a 2x bonus when you get rewarded with coins. (I have that bonus for Cart Surfer, now it's much easier for me to earn coins! ) Members can decorate their stamp book however they want, with up to 6 of their stamps/pins/mission medals to put on. Unfortunately, the release of stamps had a side effect: Nonmembers can't play more than a couple of levels of some games they used to be able to play the full version of. Why? Because members needed member-only stamps. -_-
In Fantage, you get medals. Everyone here probably know how medals work. You get levels from them, and of course, members are able to get more. (But as I've taken advantage of the medals nons can earn, I've got the whopping high nonmember level of 75. ) You get to display them on your IDfone.
Who's better when it comes to the Achievement system? Your mileage may vary on this one, honestly.
Age: Club Penguin launched 24th October 2005. My penguin joined 17th June 2006, which makes my penguin OLDER THAN FANTAGE. Whew, imagine that.
As for Fantage, I have no idea about their launch date. But I know it launched sometime in 2008, though. Which makes it younger than Club Penguin.
Missions: In Club Penguin, there was a PenguinSecretAgency which had missions. Pretty awesome missions too, and they were challenging(Unless you used a walkthrough). At the end, you got a medal item. There are some side missions too, and you get a gift at the end for doing more than you were supposed to.
Click here to see the first and last Club Penguin mission:
From the first mission, released waaay back in 2006...
Oh, nostalgia.
To the last one, released this year...
Now, good old PSA has exploded due to that wicked Herbert sneaking a popcorn bomb inside the HQ, and the now less-secret ElitePenguinForce has taken over. Now, there is a mini-mission every week, you earn some kind of currency called "Medals" from them(one per field-op). You can get some pretty nifty agent stuff in exchange for them if you're a member. If you're a non, you can get a... I dunno really what it is, but at least there's something for nons. To join this special agent thing, you'll have to pass a test. For PSA, you used to answer some questions once your penguin turned 30 days old, and POOF! You're an agent, with a spy phone and access to HQ. When I became a secret agent back in 2006, I had to log out and log in again to see if I had answered every question correctly. Back then, I thought it was SOO COOL. But as time went by, almost every penguin was a "secret" agent, and everyone knew about it. People even said that they were one. It wasn't so cool anymore. Then the HQ(and Sport Shop) exploded, and EPF stepped in, and now you have to get invited by somebody anonymous to become an agent. Then you have to pass a practical test.
In Fantage, missions are done all over the Fantage world itself. Well, except for the last one, which was awful. And way too short. You barely did anything. But all the other ones? Those were decent. But they pretty much followed the same pattern; look for something, find the villain, eventually do a minigame. At least that was my impression. Everyone is an agent automatically, at least that I know of. Only members get medals from most missions. Nons only get a medal from the first one.
Who's better when it comes to missions? Club Penguin rules over Fantage at this area, no doubt.
Non-Membership? In Club Penguin, non-members get: - Party items - Pins and flag pins - Backgrounds - Up to two puffles; former members gets to keep their puffles - Some of the stamps - Card-Jitsu belts and the ninja mask; become a ninja - A few mission items; all medals you get from missions - Play most games - Earn coins - Get to wear coin-code items - Visit almost every room, except for some party rooms and Fire and Water dojos - Become an EPF agent - Chat - An unfurnishable igloo to keep their puffle in
Of course, the catch phrase for membership is "Membership means More".
In Fantage, nons get: - Buy a few non-member items from each catalog - Get Rare items from Wizard's Domain - Play every game - Earn Stars - Earn a few medals - Level up - Two moodies - Half of the creatures(not pets, creatures) - Furnish their igloo home with a few non-member furniture - Two ugly Pebbles - Any item, as long as they have the eCoins for it
I might add more when I think of it.
And...Gah, this got longer than expected. I hope nobody went all tl;dr on me. My point? They're pretty equal. But I like Club Penguin better, honestly.
racchel2107 wrote:
ya club penguin is useless because the only thing you see is penguins wobbling everywhere
i vote for fantage at least its more realistic then club penguins theres only penguins whats so cool bout that!?
You call Fantage realistic? With its pet-collecting and hoverboards? Changing your friggin' HAIR whenever you want? Fantage is useless, too. But they both exist for one reason: That kids should have some FUN. Fun is useless, but it's fun anyway. And to answer your question, penguins are cool. At least for some people, like me. In fact, they're my favorite animal, even before I joined CP. And that was why I joined it, because of the penguins and the ability to meet other people.
♥cherry♥ Senior Fantagian
Posts : 436 Join date : 2010-12-09 Location : Up your butt and around the corner
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 24, 2010 10:24 am
Ok ill tell u the differences.
In Fantage[/u] you look like a real person. And just because your a non member in fantage you can still get clothing,boards,hair and much much more. But members can get anything they want.The only way for nons to get member things is if they have Ecoins.
In Club Penguin[/u] your just a friggin animal. Everyone looks the same and sometimes you cant tell each other apart. When your a non member u cant get ANY clothing at all. Plus u cant get any furniture for your house. And in Club Penguin there are no special money for nons to get member things.
That my friends is why in Fantage non-members can get more things then Club Penguin Oh ya and Club Penguin is kinda BORING THERE IS NOTHING TO EVEN DO!!
Bloobu Dedicated Fantagian
Posts : 1100 Join date : 2010-06-05 Age : 24
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 24, 2010 11:06 am
Nothing. To me they are similar, both are virtual worlds and both are games. They might have different pets and characters but to be honest, if you choose one you are experiencing the other.
lole1239 Regular Fantagian
Posts : 214 Join date : 2010-12-15 Age : 23 Location : somewhere in the world
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 24, 2010 11:10 am
well i think that fantage is not that realistic because hovercrafts? mom tryouts they dont have those in real life do they? gems? lucky bobs trading thing or whatever? pods? ptds? you see where i am going right? well its not that realistic. club penguin: puffs really? talking penguins? and on and on and on............
i do like fantage better than club penguin.
♥cherry♥ Senior Fantagian
Posts : 436 Join date : 2010-12-09 Location : Up your butt and around the corner
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 24, 2010 11:40 am
errrrrr?
Trash Loyal Fantagian
Posts : 1685 Join date : 2010-01-31 Age : 25
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 24, 2010 11:55 am
Actually I just preffer CP.They have those lay stages that are super cool you can control [Mag, i think you forgot that!] And then there's this cute thing where you throw snowballs and stuff
And on spacial occasions they hav REAL cool events where you can actually have fun, not like fantage, where its a different theme and just a game house you use to win cash.
Magdaleena Expert Fantagian
Posts : 2261 Join date : 2010-04-26 Age : 28 Location : Somewhere in northern Europe. Probably hours ahead of you.
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 24, 2010 12:54 pm
sissy769 wrote:
Ok ill tell u the differences.
In Fantage[/u] you look like a real person. And just because your a non member in fantage you can still get clothing,boards,hair and much much more. But members can get anything they want.The only way for nons to get member things is if they have Ecoins.
In Club Penguin[/u] your just a friggin animal. Everyone looks the same and sometimes you cant tell each other apart. When your a non member u cant get ANY clothing at all. Plus u cant get any furniture for your house. And in Club Penguin there are no special money for nons to get member things.
That my friends is why in Fantage non-members can get more things then Club Penguin Oh ya and Club Penguin is kinda BORING THERE IS NOTHING TO EVEN DO!!
Real person? Since when did real people have heads about the size of their bodies? And as a nonmember you CAN get clothing. New nonmembers do get less than those nonmembers who joined in like, 2006-07, I can agree with that. But hats and belts do qualify as clothes, right? Treasure books allow nonmembers to look like members. But to get access to a treasure book, you'll have to buy a toy with a coin code on it.
Trash wrote:
Actually I just preffer CP.They have those lay stages that are super cool you can control [Mag, i think you forgot that!] And then there's this cute thing where you throw snowballs and stuff
And on spacial occasions they hav REAL cool events where you can actually have fun, not like fantage, where its a different theme and just a game house you use to win cash.
Ohhh, right, I forgot that part. ^^;
And there is actually a Holiday Party going on there right now. You may want to check it out if you haven't already.
♥cherry♥ Senior Fantagian
Posts : 436 Join date : 2010-12-09 Location : Up your butt and around the corner
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 24, 2010 2:53 pm
ugh ment that clothing as in jackets shoes pants (but i dont see them wear pants)
pokeranger Hero Fantagian
Posts : 5454 Join date : 2010-01-29 Age : 25 Location : Loading...
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 24, 2010 8:12 pm
Weirdly, Clubpenguin seems much much better. But i must say, my penguin is so fat. ;P Fantage, you barel have the privelege(or however you spell it) to get clothes as a nonmember. Yes, Clubpenguin doesn't really give that good of clothes for a non, but my inventory filled! It's easier to earn coins for stuff, but Fantage is a toughy for me. Clubpenguin is so fun when I was eight. I gave up on it when I lost my membership. And ironically, I got to Fantage. Being a nonmember on Clubpenguin is much more fun then a nonmember on Fantage, no offense.
This makes me feel like making a new clubpenguin. -o- Tata
Magdaleena Expert Fantagian
Posts : 2261 Join date : 2010-04-26 Age : 28 Location : Somewhere in northern Europe. Probably hours ahead of you.
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Sat Dec 25, 2010 9:49 am
FreedoM 4EVA wrote:
Both are virtual worlds, and both have their own things. In CP you get monthly coins of (i guess) 350 or 360 if you are an EPF agent or even a tour guide. Its another thing, once you are 30 days old you can even be a tour guide after taking a short test. (Mag, you forgot about the tour?)
To me Fantage is good but, CP is better.
Pretty much proves that there are so much stuff to do there, that even I can't remember all of it at once.
For being a tour guide you get 250 each month, for being an EPF agent you get 350 each month. On the subject of post cards, right now there is a post card that works like a gift; you send it to another penguin for 10 coins, and the receiver gets a free hat from the post card. You may want to ask others for a gift, so you can get one as well.
Could you imagine Fantage coming up with an idea like that? I can't...
In case anyone haven't noticed it yet... yes, I like Club Penguin better. No offense to the haters, we all have opinions.
AsianPanda New Fantagian
Posts : 7 Join date : 2010-12-25 Age : 23
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Sat Dec 25, 2010 3:48 pm
In Fantage it's with humans instead of chubby penguins it's actually very profound if you think of it both are nice but I must say Fantage because you don't have to be a member to buy something.
bladerunner22 Devoted Fantagian
Posts : 530 Join date : 2010-11-27 Age : 24 Location : Asia
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Sat Dec 25, 2010 3:51 pm
In my opinion, I really like both. I keep switching from Fantage to CP and etc.
MsJoyMaeda Hero Fantagian
Posts : 5830 Join date : 2010-12-13 Age : 24
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Mon Dec 27, 2010 8:33 pm
I perfer fantage because i don't go on clubpenguin very much
Magdaleena Expert Fantagian
Posts : 2261 Join date : 2010-04-26 Age : 28 Location : Somewhere in northern Europe. Probably hours ahead of you.
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Tue Dec 28, 2010 4:49 pm
AsianPanda wrote:
...instead of chubby penguins...
Actually, I've never really looked at the penguins themselves as chubby. Call me weird if you want, because I know I am.
But some items, however, can make them look pretty fat. I tend to stay away from wearing those.
As for the common statement of "At least we don't have to be a member to buy something in Fantage"... It's a little bit misinformed. (If you talked about furniture and clothing, however...)
In fact, you can actually buy something from the catalog as a non-member. Only the clothes are for members. And the entire furniture and ninja catalog. Three types of items from the gift shop catalog are for everyone; Colors, player card backgrounds, and flag pins. There are way too many who take those kinds of items as granted...
MizFanTageZ New Fantagian
Posts : 12 Join date : 2010-12-30 Age : 24
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Thu Dec 30, 2010 2:59 pm
Wow there similiar in tons and tons of ways! In clubpenguin you can actually sit, theres no boards and ur smaller and to tell u the truth its funner! But in Fantage there are boards the clothes and hair are better and ur actually a human! But Im mad cause after I got bannded a couple of times on cp and then got bannded one more time I GOT BANNDED FOREVER! Then I sent them emails but they said I can only get unbanned if I send them a member recipt, and I dont have it! My acount was awsome and I'm not making another! Anyways Im better with Fantage! > FANTAGE IS STARTING TO BE WAY MORE AWSOMER THEN CP TRUST ME ITS GETTING THERE!
pat Veteran Fantagian
Posts : 4245 Join date : 2010-12-29 Age : 22 Location : USA
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Fri Dec 31, 2010 7:35 pm
racchel2107 wrote:
ya club penguin is useless because the only thing you see is penguins wobbling everywhere
i vote for fantage at least its more realistic then club penguins theres only penguins whats so cool bout that!?
i agree pandanda comes after fantage for me...
Kairi Junior Fantagian
Posts : 68 Join date : 2010-12-23 Age : 26 Location : on a random server
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Sun Mar 13, 2011 4:06 am
Technically fantage is better because club penguin is gay u gotta admit
Cherry_fine Junior Fantagian
Posts : 51 Join date : 2011-02-04
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Sun Mar 13, 2011 8:15 am
and there is one diffrence when you make a new account ou dont have to activate it if u wantt u can wait 1 hour :I
Magdaleena Expert Fantagian
Posts : 2261 Join date : 2010-04-26 Age : 28 Location : Somewhere in northern Europe. Probably hours ahead of you.
Subject: Re: Club Penguin vs. Fantage Sun Mar 13, 2011 8:45 am
pinkiepie100 wrote:
Technically fantage is better because club penguin is gay u gotta admit
On a more serious note, that's like saying "Technically Club Penguin is better because Fantage is gay, you gotta admit." Give me some real reasons, not just something entirely based on your opinion only.
Personally, I think Club Penguin is better. The pets, the missions, the parties, the emotes are all made better than Fantage's... plus the fact that it's older, so the staff is (or should be) more experienced.
Let's not forget the fact that I just love penguins.