Well, as a few people said, it's your opinion. I mean, if I were you, I would try it out for myself. Don't take our word for it, because you might like it better than some people on here. You might even hate Club Penguin, who knows?
Although last time I checked (I haven't played Club Penguin for a long time so excuse if I'm incorrect), Club Penguin's membership prices were higher than Fantage. And you get pretty much nothing without a membership (no clothes, no furniture, etc.). But come on guys, this is Disney we're talking about. Of course Club Penguin is more overpriced than Fantage; it's owned by Disney. I'm sure Club Penguin can be really fun if you ignore this whole ordeal about overpriced membership and whatnot.
So basically, I don't know. It could be fun for you, or you may not like the game due to the lack of stuff you can do/get without a membership. Even though I myself have gotten bored of Club Penguin over the years, don't take my word for it. Go try it out for yourself.